The Hub

BRUINS 1
Joined: 1/28/05 Posts: 19,758
Things I don’t get
Posted Mon, May 06 8:57 am (Edited Mon, May 06 8:57 am)
Among many, why graduate transfers are so taboo, yet, undergraduate admissions of students who would not otherwise get in is fine? You don’t think that they are taking up the spot of a serious student with better academic credentials? Who is the bigger academic risk, an undergraduate, who in most recent history has ZERO desire to get their degree let alone see their junior year, or a graduate transfer who has already shown that they are committed to school given that they have a college degree?

No one is saying to fill the roster, but it can be a good way to get help and fill gaps.
This page is in overload mode. If you wish to read all messages, please click here.
cnet
Joined: 8/07/14 Posts: 9,697
Undergraduates can enter as an undeclared major
Posted Mon, May 06 9:16 am
In response to Things I don’t get (BRUINS 1)
A graduate transfer has to be admitted with a very specific specialty and they had better prepared for that specialty as an undergrad.

Go Bruins!
Arrive early. Wear Blue. Be loud.

OswegoBruin
Joined: 11/11/10 Posts: 16,935
Any grad student will tell you
Posted Mon, May 06 9:26 am
In response to Things I don’t get (BRUINS 1)
A masters is far, FAR more difficult to obtain than an undergraduate degree. Especially at a place like UCLA, which in terms of overall graduate program value is no lower than fourth west of the rockies. Graduate programs also do not have "turnover", ie most kids in them finish them, whereas most undergraduate programs have kids jumping in and out frequently.
Replies to this subthread

BastieBruin
Joined: 12/13/11 Posts: 2,939


Avatars available for donors only
I think it's about who is making the admission decision
Posted Mon, May 06 10:47 am
In response to Things I don’t get (BRUINS 1)
When you apply as an undergrad to the general pool, Murphy Hall is admitting everybody, and there is a general understanding that they will be allocating spots for athletes who otherwise would not be admitted. Students may later have to apply for specific majors that are "impacted" by over-enrollment, but that's a separate decision.

When you apply to grad school, I believe you are applying directly to the individual department itself, and admissions decisions are made there. For example, you apply to the "School of Engineering" or the "School of Education", etc. There are far fewer of these enrollment slots to begin with, and the individual graduate schools have zero incentive or desire to set aside enrollment slots for athletes at the expense of students that they perceive as more qualified and committed. This problem is exacerbated due to the history of grad transfers bailing on UCLA as soon as their one season is over. Or even sooner, since grades often don't come out until after the season. From the perspective of the individual grad schools, this is a complete waste of an enrollment slot.

I don't know how this is handled at other schools, but I could see it being a pretty tough nut to crack at UCLA.
Replies to this subthread

ShowtimeUCLA
Joined: 11/19/17 Posts: 1,974
I think graduate school is a different beast
Posted Mon, May 06 1:52 pm
In response to Things I don’t get (BRUINS 1)
My undergrad experience was nothing like grad school. I did both at UCLA (I’m a loyal Bruin). Undergrad was just very laid back, at least for my major, political science. I was a psychology major early on and it was more challenging. That’s the luxury of undergrad. You can pick certain majors and game the system with certain courses and professors. Grad school is nothing like that. They have a strict curriculum and limited flexibility. Students tend to be far more serious too and everything is graded on a curve like system which basically pits you against other students. I couldn’t imagine how someone could be an athlete in graduate school.
Replies to this subthread

88Straight
Joined: 8/17/15 Posts: 4,489


Avatars available for donors only
They aren’t taking an undergraduates spot
Posted Mon, May 06 7:08 pm (Edited Mon, May 06 7:16 pm)
In response to Things I don’t get (BRUINS 1)
Because a number of scholarships are planned upon from the jump.

Graduate transfers have to be admitted because there are a limited number of slots and they are for real students, not someone who just wants to be enrolled for basketball.

Beyond that, I think you are overstating the impact versus just recruiting well and developing your players.

Perhaps they could be admitted as an undergrad pursuing a 2nd degree in a different major?
Replies to this subthread